The Best Fresh and Original Food in the Neighborhood…
Lawrenceville and Northside

My father always told me that I should own a deli because people always need to eat. That's why I've worked with food for over 20 years.  

- Gary Gigliotti

SOUP w/ BREADSTICKS
12 oz Wedding $4.25
12 oz Soup of the Day $4.75


SALADS
CHEF $7.25
Mixed greens, tomatoes, egg, turkey and ham, Swiss and American cheeses.
‍
DELI COBB $7.75
Mixed greens, chicken breast, crumbled bacon, tomatoes, cucumber, eggs, sliced avocados and blue cheese crumbles.
‍
CAESAR $5.25 (V)
Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, parmesan cheese and caesar dressing. Add chicken ($2 extra)

GREEK $5.50 (V)
Romaine lettuce, chicken breast, red onion, Kalamata olives, feta cheese, banana peppers. Add Chicken ($2 extra)
‍
BIG TOSSED SALAD $5.50 (V)
Mixed greens, tomatoES, cucumbers, black olives, eggs, and provolone cheese.

SPECIALTY SANDWICHES
Choice of bread unless otherwise specified—Italian, Marble Rye, Whole Wheat. Also served with a pickle spear.

SOUP & SANDWICH SPECIAL $9.50
1/2 any Speciality Sandwich or Panini and choice of wedding soup or soup of the day.
‍
PASQUALE $9.25
Roast beef, ham and turkey, red onions, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and Colby cheese and the Deli’s special sauce.
‍
MARIE $8.75
Pastrami, Swiss cheese, cole slaw and deli sauce on rye bread. Served hot or cold.

MUFFALETTA $8.75
Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham and provolone cheese. Topped with roasted red peppers and a home made olive spread. Served on sliced foccacia.

HOMEMADE TUNA, EGG or CHICKEN SALAD $8.75
The Deli’s homemade chicken, egg or tuna salad (my mom’s secret recipe).

PEPPER & EGG $8.75 (V)
Scrambled eggs with red & green peppers on a 6” hoagie roll served with lettuce, tomato, provolone and mayo.

TERESA'S ARROSTO DIMANZO $8.75
Roast beef, provolone cheese, horseradish sauce, giardiniera, lettuce and tomato on a 6” hoagie bun.
‍
COBB ON BREAD $8.75
Roasted chicken breast, blue cheese crumbles, bacon, egg,avocado with lettuce, tomato, and mayo.

AMERICAN CLUB $8.75
Turkey, Ham, Swiss cheese and bacon crumbles with lettuce, tomato and mayo.

CHICKEN ITALIANO $8.75
Chicken breast, asiago cheese, red peppers, banana peppers, lettuce, tomato, Italian seasoning, and red pepper pesto on Italian bread.

CASEY'S TURKEY BACON RANCH $8.75
Turkey, bacon crumbles, ranch, asiago cheese, tomatoes, lettuce onItalian bread.

PANINIS
Paninis are served hot on the inside and toasted on the outside.

AVOCADO BLUE $8.75
Oven-roasted turkey, blue cheese crumbles, bacon, avocado pesto and honey mustard.
‍
CHICKEN PESTO $8.50
Roasted chicken breast, provolone cheese, green pesto sauce.

SPICY CHICKEN $8.50
Chipolte chicken, chipolte gouda, pineapple mayo.
‍
BRISKET SANDWICH $9.75
Mesquite smokehouse brisket with BBQ sauce, coleslaw, cheddar cheese on Italian bread.

CHICKEN & ARTICHOKE $8.50
Roasted chicken breast, provolone cheese, and the Deli’s special artichoke spread.
‍
MEDITERRANEAN $8.50
Roasted chicken breast, red pepper pesto, feta cheese, Kalamata olives.

CHICKEN CORDON BLEU $8.50
Roasted chicken breast, ham, swiss cheese

BEEF & BLEU $8.50
Roast beef, blue cheese, caramelized red onions.

FIVE CHEESE & BACON $8.50 (V)
Provolone, asiago, cheddar, American and Swiss cheeses, bacon. With or without tomatoes.

CAPRESE $8.50 (V)
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, fresh basil, or green pesto.

ITALIAN $8.50
Salami, Capicola, pepperoni, ham, red peppers, provolone cheese.

VEGGIE $8.50 (V)
Hummus, sliced cucumber, black olives, roasted red peppers, onions, lettuce, tomato and feta cheese drizzled with balsamic reduction served on wheat bread.

HOAGIES
Served on a 6" or 12” Italian roll.

TUTTI $8.75/$12.00
An Italian sub with generous amounts of Genoa salami, capicola, ham, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, roasted red pepper, black olives and the Deli’s signature oil.
‍
AMERICAN $8.75/$11.00
Piles of ham and turkey, american cheese, lettuce and tomato.

TURKEY AND CHEESE $8.75/$11.00
Piles of roasted turkey, Provolone, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.

WRAPS

CHICKEN CAESAR $8.50
Chicken breast, crispy romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing, Parmesan cheese in a flour tortilla.
‍
TURKEY & SMOKED GOUDA $8.75
Turkey, cranberries, romaine lettuce, and sweet potato mayo.

BUFFALO CHICKEN $8.75
Buffalo chicken breast, blue cheese crumbles, lettuce and tomato, ranch dressing and hot sauce in a flour tortilla.
‍
VEGGIE WRAP $8.50 (V)
Hummus, spring mix, roasted red pepper, cucumber, olives, onion, tomato, and feta on flour, wheat, or garlic wrap.

COBB WRAP $8.75
Sliced chicken breast, blue cheese crumbles, bacon, egg, avocado, lettuce, tomato and mayo
‍
ZACH’S SOUTHWEST $8.75
Sliced chicken breast, chipotle ranch, sauteed peppers and onions, coleslaw, and pepperjack cheese.

My father, Pasquale Gigliotti told me from a very young age that I should be a butcher or own a deli because, “people always need to eat.”  I sort of followed his advice by being in restaurant management for the last 20 years.  I managed Dingbats in Fox Chapel, Bar Louie & Red Star in Station Square and finally Mario’s on the South side.  But in the back of my mind, owning my own business was still a dream.  In 2006, my father passed away and it was then that I realized that it was time for a life change.  I sat down with my sisters, Kathy and Patti as well as a few close friends to discuss the possibilities of opening a Deli…and that’s where the idea for the Deli on Butler Street was born.  After that moment, everything seemed to fall into place:  finding the great location on Butler Street in Lawrenceville, my sister Patti’s financial backing, my cousin PJ in Chicago creating the fantastic logo, and my partner and long-time friend, Pete designing and decorating the interior and working with me to get the Deli opened.

This truly is a family run business.  My mother, Mary as well as my Aunt Judy work at the Deli on Butler street. My sister Patti makes the soups and some cookies,   My nephew Mike and nieces Gina and Dana along with childhood friend, Joan, helped with menu ideas and the rest of my family and friends offered tons of advice and moral support.  With this mix I knew we’d be a success.  When you visit the Deli on Butler Street, we like to treat you as if you’re coming into our family kitchen.  So thank you for giving me the opportunity to fulfill my dream at my father’s advice and serve the warm community of Lawrenceville. 

- Gary Gigliotti, Proprietor